The scientific method—characterized by systematic observation, hypothesis formation, empirical testing, and generalization—is the foundation of the natural sciences, such as physics and biology. The question of whether sociology qualifies as a science depends on its ability to adopt this method to study social phenomena objectively.
While sociology does not deal with physical laws like natural sciences, it applies systematic research methods to study human behavior, social structures, and institutions. This makes sociology a social science, distinct from natural sciences but still following a structured methodology. Émile Durkheim’s work, particularly his study on suicide (1897), exemplifies how sociology applies the scientific method to uncover patterns in human behavior, supporting its claim as a science.
Key Features of the Scientific Method in Sociology
- Empirical Observation – Collecting data through surveys, experiments, or historical records to ensure objectivity.
- Hypothesis Formation – Proposing testable explanations for social behaviors and phenomena.
- Objectivity – Minimizing researcher bias by using replicable, transparent methods.
- Generalizability – Identifying patterns that can be applied beyond individual cases to explain societal trends.
Durkheim’s Scientific Approach in Suicide
Durkheim sought to challenge the idea that suicide was purely an individual psychological act by applying systematic, empirical research. His methodology involved:
1. Empirical Data Collection
- Data Source: Durkheim analyzed suicide rates across different European countries using official statistics rather than personal testimonies.
- Example: His study revealed that Protestants had higher suicide rates than Catholics, which he attributed to differences in social integration.
2. Hypothesis Testing
- Hypothesis: Suicide rates are influenced by social facts such as integration (social connectedness) and regulation (societal control).
- Variables: Durkheim identified four types of suicide:
- Egoistic Suicide – Due to low social integration (e.g., unmarried individuals, isolated persons).
- Altruistic Suicide – Due to excessive integration (e.g., soldiers sacrificing for the nation).
- Anomic Suicide – Due to lack of social regulation (e.g., economic crises leading to instability).
- Fatalistic Suicide – Due to excessive regulation (e.g., people under extreme oppression).
3. Objectivity in Analysis
- Durkheim treated suicide not as an individual choice but as a societal phenomenon, similar to how natural sciences study forces like gravity.
- He focused on patterns rather than personal motives, making his approach replicable and testable.
4. Generalizable Conclusions
- Durkheim’s study revealed law-like patterns—suicide rates were consistent across similar social conditions.
- Predictive Power: His framework remains relevant today, explaining rising suicide rates in individualistic societies where social bonds are weaker.
Why Durkheim’s Method Supports Sociology as a Science
- Systematic Approach – His use of statistical data and comparative methods aligns with natural science methodologies.
- Falsifiability – His hypotheses could be tested and modified (e.g., later studies criticized his neglect of mental health factors).
- Theoretical Foundation – His study established sociology as an empirical discipline rather than mere philosophical speculation.
Limitations of the Scientific Method in Sociology
Despite its structured approach, sociology faces unique challenges:
- Complex Variables – Unlike natural sciences, human behavior involves consciousness, emotions, culture, and ethics, making it harder to establish universal laws.
- Example: Durkheim overlooked individual agency, treating suicide as a product of social forces alone.
- Ethical Constraints – Unlike chemistry or physics, experiments in sociology (e.g., manipulating poverty or crime) are often unethical.
- Subjectivity in Interpretation – Interpretivists argue that verstehen (subjective understanding) is essential to grasp human experiences beyond mere statistics.
Conclusion: Sociology as a Social Science
Durkheim’s Suicide study shows that sociology can apply the scientific method to uncover social laws. However, its focus on human agency, culture, and ethics distinguishes it from natural sciences. Therefore, sociology is best classified as a social science—combining empirical rigor with interpretive depth to analyze complex phenomena like inequality, globalization, and cultural change.